Welcome! | Log In
MESA SERVER | Year: 66 Era: 9

HGG Community Forums

Please show us your best "Vanner" Horse Reference Images - Hunt and Jump Forum - Mesa
Log In to HorseGeneticsGame
Members log in here:
Username:
Password:

By hitting the above you signify that you agree with our rules and conditions.
Forgot your password?
HGG Community Forums

Join our discord server!

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

In this Discussion

Please show us your best "Vanner" Horse Reference Images
  • What makes a good reference photo? Images should have:

    -Bright, clear lighting, without overly dark shadows
    -Be side-on shots with the photo taken square to the shoulder, like the current images in the game.
    -Be good examples of the breed type.
    -Show as much of the horse as possible, tall grass hides a lot of leg details.
    -Bonus if we can clearly see at least some of each leg.
    -Limited, or ideally no tack at all.


    -In addition to the nice square on body shots if you have an image of a body part (like a head, mane, tail etc.) that you think is particularly nice feel free to share it, including the reason you are sharing, but we need square full body shots more than anything. The body part in question should be clearly labeled and must STILL be square to the camera. We can't use the images otherwise.

    We need adult horses AND foal images.

    Please don't share images of "pretty horses" that do not fit what is outlined above. It bogs things down and makes it harder on us.

    ______

    We ALSO need a discussion about the name of this breed.

    "Gypsy Vanner" is a US-specific term for cobs bred in the UK by the Travelers/Gypsy/Romani people. It is very important to note that "Gypsy" is considered a very offensive racist term any many parts of the world, but nomadic people are not a monolith and different cultures of nomadic people call themselves different things. The ones I have met in the US call themselves Romani. In Bulgaria, the posters for their festivals use the word Romanai in English but they mostly go by Tsiganin in Bulgarian. As I understand in the UK Gypsy is often the preferred word. The Traveler people have their own cultural identity and heritage that is completely unique from the Roma people, and they are not interchangeable groups despite sharing horse genetics.

    I am not here to shame anyone for saying "gypsy" but we are also not going to use that word in the game out of respect for my personal friends in the US and Bulgaria who are Romani.

    Up to now, I have been using the word Vanner as it is easily identifiable what breed I am speaking about. I am however very open to calling them something else. I have seen Irish Cob and Galineers Cob suggested.
    Need to contact me? Read this first.

    I sometimes get busy and miss things. If your private message, question, etc. gets missed please ping me so I can follow up with you. I am also always happy to explain or clarify. (HAJ does not have a customer service email, please send me a forum message! )


    she/her
  • These horses are just so beautiful. I'm not sure how to put the pictures directly here, so I'll just use Imgur.
    https://imgur.com/a/vKlC8zx
    The foals are so cute!

    Also, I think that Vanner is just fine, but Irish Cob/Galineers Cob seems great! Galineers Cob seems to be the name that comes up first when you search for either Irish Cob or (Gypsy) Vanner on Google, but I personally don’t really care. I’m here for all the pretty horses!
    DarkPhoenix #15470 (she/her) ~ Premium Upgrade
    Barns always open!
  • I like Vanner because I instantly knew what you meant and it removes the conflict point.
  • I feel using Vanner is appropriate and leaves out any cultural reference.

    I found nice pictures, however I can't figure out the picture posting without Imgur.
  • Stallion
    image host
    image host maybe a mini
    image host gelding I think
    Foal
    image host
    Mare
    image host
    image host
    Just for fun Miniature Vanner
    image host
    Blue Grass id#: 182429
    Forest id#: 289
    Mesa id#: 351
  • Posted this on forest:

    Vanner is not what the people who created this breed call it though. Americans who exported their breed (for better or worse) came up with that so I am hesitant to use it only because Americans know it better. I don't think it is a bad term, just others might be better.
    Need to contact me? Read this first.

    I sometimes get busy and miss things. If your private message, question, etc. gets missed please ping me so I can follow up with you. I am also always happy to explain or clarify. (HAJ does not have a customer service email, please send me a forum message! )


    she/her
  • I am good with Irish Cob, Vanner or any other name if fine. The folks who brought the Vanner to America got the Gypsy Vanner name from man they met in UK, they where looking for a different type of Draft horse, when they saw a beautiful Cob in a pasture. The folks who had the pasture told the American couple who the owner was, he called himself a Gypsy, he was an older gentleman. He was the one who suggested Vanner and so the Gypsy Vanner registry was created by this Couple in America. I know a farm in the UK uses the term Gypsy Pony or Cob but I think they sale the horses to Americans, so they use the term because that is how the Americans know the breed best.
    Blue Grass id#: 182429
    Forest id#: 289
    Mesa id#: 351
  • I like Irish Cob ♡

    Also going to try the picture thing lol

    image

    image

    image
  • From what research I can find it seems like "cob" is the name the Romani use for this breed. Vanner is a term created by Americans. I feel it is always the most respectful to call things what the people who created them want them to be called. So "Irish Cob" might be our best bet here.
    Need to contact me? Read this first.

    I sometimes get busy and miss things. If your private message, question, etc. gets missed please ping me so I can follow up with you. I am also always happy to explain or clarify. (HAJ does not have a customer service email, please send me a forum message! )


    she/her
  • @Ammit. Irish Cob is fine by me but in defense of Americans since I am and a Native American too, most us never think of the word Gypsy as bad, but we have never deal with folk that gave the word Gypsy it's bad reputation either or in my case never been faced with it, but I get it. I breed dogs and We who breed for the right reasons are often thrown in with the puppy mill group, so if it makes everyone feel better use what ever name you wish too. I think Vanner for the breed is fine since that was what the horse was bred for - to pull a caravan or Van, so Vanner for me is a good name too. But again what ever you wish to do is fine.
    Blue Grass id#: 182429
    Forest id#: 289
    Mesa id#: 351
    Thanked by 1Cavalynn
  • I'm in several genetics groups on the internet and a lot of them have been using 'Irish Cob' to refer to Vanners. A lot of Americans, at least in the horse community, are making the switch to Irish Cob or even 'Vanner Cob'. Lots of different variants but I think 'irish Cob' is the most familiar to a lot.
    On a slightly related tangent, I've also seen debates about people switching to using 'Grulla' to reference black duns instead of 'Grullo' as apparently the latter is an ableist slur in Italian? Not sure the authenticity of that, but a lot of terminology seems to be switching around in the horse community for the better and its great.
  • That grullo thing is totally BS. For one thing, grullo and grulla are the same word. They are just different genders. If this was true changing to grulla would not solve anything. They are also Spanish words. We don't change words in one language because the word might be problematic in a completely different language. For example, it would be absurd to insist the many languages that use the word "negro" for black change their languages because Americans made it into a slur.

    The most damning though is that I have only ever seen Americans claim that. Actual Italians have been pretty clear that it's not true. Italians aren't asking anyone to change the color names of horses. I am sure the people spreading this myth mean well but it's just a myth and has more to do with virtue signaling than respecting other cultures.
    Need to contact me? Read this first.

    I sometimes get busy and miss things. If your private message, question, etc. gets missed please ping me so I can follow up with you. I am also always happy to explain or clarify. (HAJ does not have a customer service email, please send me a forum message! )


    she/her
  • Had to research* the Grullo thing, as my husband is Italian American... Seems that grulla is just the feminine of grullo, so wouldn't make a difference.

    *Spent 2 minutes Google-ing
  • Thank you for clearing that up. Makes way more sense!
    They're so deadset on using only 'grulla' in those groups to the point that even if people screenshot research saying 'hey, that's not right' or tried to argue the claim they'd just boot you for using it anyways, it got confusing. American internet circles are a mess, I'm starting to realize.
  • The amount many Americans forget the rest of the world exists at all is flabbergasting sometimes. :-S
    Sorry not currently taking any request for egg/straw/horse sales. Everything I have for sale is already listed.
  • I think in the end we are going to go with "Traditional Cob" for these. It is not my favorite name but it does pay respect to the breeds of Ireland AND Britan who created this intermingled breed we know as the Vanner in the US. Plus with the information that The Irish Cob Society has been succeeded by "The Traditional Cob Registry." (https://www.theirishcobsociety.com/ https://www.tcr.onl/ ) It seems like the way the breed is moving is as far as naming goes.
    Need to contact me? Read this first.

    I sometimes get busy and miss things. If your private message, question, etc. gets missed please ping me so I can follow up with you. I am also always happy to explain or clarify. (HAJ does not have a customer service email, please send me a forum message! )


    she/her
  • Yep I see that too :)
    Blue Grass id#: 182429
    Forest id#: 289
    Mesa id#: 351

Join our discord server!